# Sherlock and Permutations

# Sherlock and Permutations

VamsiSangam + 15 comments The given problem is simple and reduces to -

**(N + M - 1)**!

--------------**(M - 1)! (N)!**

Now, let's keep it super simple and say, we put the Numerator in a variable '**Nr**' and the Denominator in a variable '**Dr**'. Now, we are supposed to calculate,

**(Nr / Dr) % P**, where '**P**' is the given prime**(10**^{9}+ 7)

We could write the above expression as,

**(Nr * Dr**,^{-1}) % P

Now we can apply the principle of modular arithematic,

**(a * b) % p = ((a % p) * (b % p)) % p**,

So, Applying the above principle, we get,

**(Nr * Dr**,^{-1}) % P = ((Nr % P) * (Dr^{-1}% P)) % P

Now, using Fermat's Little Theorem, we can replace the '**Dr**' term and the equation becomes,^{-1}

**(Nr * Dr**,^{-1}) % P = ((Nr % P) * (Dr^{(P - 2)}% P)) % P

Now, calculating**(Nr % P)**is simple, we use the above used modular arithematic principle, and the term**(Dr**can be calculated by using the technique stated in the link provided by the editorial.^{(P - 2)}% P)

But the problem is, that '**Dr**' over there, itself can be very big. We have techniques to calculate '**x**', but in our case this '^{y}% P**x**' is itself damn big. That is, our variable '**Dr**' itself can be something like, '**(499! * 500!)**' which we cannot calculate.

Then, my question is, what value will we insert in place of '**Dr**' in the term**(Dr**.....?? How can that be calculated...?? I've been trying to find that out since several weeks. This is my confusion in many problems, please please clarify...... Thanks in advance...! :-)^{(P - 2)}% P)abhiranjan + 0 comments Ohh dear!

`(a*b)%p == ((a%p)*(b%p)) % p => 5! % 7 = (1 * 2 * 3 * 4 * 5) % 7 = ((((1 * 2)%7 * 3)%7 * 4)%7 * 5)%7 = (((2 * 3)%7 * 4)%7 * 5)%7 = (((6 * 4)%7 * 5)%7 = (24%7 * 5)%7 = (3 * 5)%7 = 15%7 = 1`

VamsiSangam + 0 comments Yes abhiranjan Sir.... I understand that very well.... What asked was... Take a test case where M = 500, N = 500, that sums to,

(999!) / (499! * 500!)

Then our formula becomes,

((999!) / (499! * 500!)) % P = ((999! % P) * ((499! * 500!) (P - 2) % P)) % P,

The first term, (999! % P) can be calculated as you told Sir, but how do I calculate the next term,

**((499! * 500!) (P - 2) % P)**.....?? Can you please explain me mathematically step-by-step, exactly as you did above....??P.S. ..... Sir, the above mentioned content means EXACTLY the same as your answer to a discussion.... I got this same doubt when I tried to understand your answer, Sir.... But I could'nt, then I ignored.... But as too many Q's were demanding this technique, I had to ask... I hope you understand... Please clarify my confusion Sir.... Thanks a lot for the reply Sir...! :-)

abhiranjan + 2 comments So, in our next step we need the help of

*higher powers*, or we need to calculate*ab %m*.`= 1 % m , b == 0 a^b = a*(a^(b-1)) % m , odd b = a'^2 % m , even b where a' = a^(b/2)`

Suppose we need to calculate

*2100 % 11*.`2^100 = (2^50)^2 (mod 11) 2^50 = (2^25)^2 (mod 11) 2^25 = 2*(2^24) (mod 11) 2^24 = (2^12)^2 (mod 11) 2^12 = (2^6)^2 (mod 11) 2^6 = (2^3)^2 (mod 11) 2^3 = 2*(2^2) (mod 11) 2^2 = (2^1)^2 (mod 11) 2^1 = 2*(2^0) (mod 11) 2^0 = 1`

Now popping whole stack,

`2^1 = 2*1 = 2 (mod 11) 2^2 = 2^2 = 4 (mod 11) 2^3 = 2*4 = 8 (mod 11) 2^6 = 8^2 = 64 = 9 (mod 11) 2^12 = 9^2 = 81 = 4 (mod 11) 2^24 = 4^2 = 16 = 5 (mod 11) 2^25 = 2*5 = 10 (mod 11) 2^50 = 10^2 = 100 = 1 (mod 11) 2^100 = 1^2 = 1 (mod 11)`

hjm921028 + 0 comments thank you very much,it works!

coolrohan123 + 0 comments Sir please check my program , I am getting wrong answer . I have implemented your concept https://www.hackerrank.com/challenges/sherlock-and-permutations/submissions/code/18386949

VamsiSangam + 0 comments Yes Sir, I understood that idea completely..... In your example you were able to calculate,

**2100 % 11**. But what if instead of that '**2**' over there, we had something like '**499! * 500!**'....??abhiranjan + 1 comment You need to calculate factorials using method posted in first reply.

`a = 499! (mod p) b = 500! (mod p) where, 0 <= a, b < p`

Now problem reduces to

`1/(a*b) = (a*b)^-1 (mod p) = c^-1 (mod p) = c^(p-2) (mod p) where, c = (a*b)%p`

Now use fast exponential method, posted in last reply, to calculate higher power.

sriv_shubham + 0 comments thanks sir...ur explanation helped to pass all test cases in 1st attempt....i always wanted to learn modular arithmetic on large numbers :)

VamsiSangam + 0 comments So, to calculate,

**(499! * 500!)(P - 2) % P**,if I store the value of,

**((499! % P) * (500! % P))**in a variable '**temp**', then my expression reduces to,**(temp)(P - 2) % P**,Am I right, Sir...??

abhiranjan + 1 comment Exactly.

mihirkarkare + 1 comment Sir, I am unable to understand how to slove this question. I have understood till the use of fermat's little theorem.

c=1; for(k=1;k<=n;k++) { c=((c%p)*(((n+m-k)%p)*(pow(k,p-2)%p)%p))%p; } //how do i compute pow(k,p-2)%p ?

levpolka + 0 comments Formula is (n+m-1)!/(n!*(m-1)!) 1. AL1 (ArrayList) contains integers from 2 to n+m-1. 2. AL2 contains integers from 2 to n and from 2 to m-1. 3. There is function returning list with primes (like it turns list {1 2 3 4 5 6} to {1 2 3 2 2 5 2 3}). 4. Delete from AL1 all elements which occur in AL2 (AL2 becomes empty). 5. Multiply all elements of AL1 by mod.

`public static void main(String[] args) { Scanner in = new Scanner(System.in); int t = in.nextInt(); while (t-- > 0) { int n = in.nextInt(); int m = in.nextInt(); ArrayList<Integer> list1 = new ArrayList<>(); ArrayList<Integer> list2 = new ArrayList<>(); for (int i = 2; i <= n + m - 1; i++) { list1.add(i); if (i <= n) list2.add(i); if (i <= m - 1) list2.add(i); } list1 = primeList(list1); list2 = primeList(list2); for (int i = 0; i < list2.size(); i++) list1.remove(list1.indexOf(list2.get(i))); long res = 1; int mod = (int) Math.pow(10, 9) + 7; for (int i = 0; i < list1.size(); i++) res = (res * list1.get(i)) % mod; System.out.println(res); } } public static ArrayList<Integer> primeList(ArrayList<Integer> list) { for (int i = 0; i < list.size(); i++) { ArrayList<Integer> primes = new ArrayList<>(); for (int j = 2; j <= (int) Math.sqrt(list.get(i)); j++) { if (list.get(i) % j == 0) { primes.add(j); list.set(i, list.get(i) / j); j--; } } list.addAll(primes); } return list; }`

VamsiSangam + 0 comments Hey, it worked.... Thanks a lot for the help, Sir...! I've been trying to learn it since ages, finally got it...! :-)

Shishir_Singhal + 2 comments sir, please tell me how can you reduce Dr^-1 to Dr^(p-2) by using little fermat's theorem..?? sir , thanks for advance .....

Shishir_Singhal + 0 comments [deleted]ahujashubham95 + 0 comments can you please explain the logic behind replacing Dr^(-1) with Dr^(p-2)??

pasupuletiganes1 + 0 comments omg y we have to calculate dr^(10000000007-2),it will be such a huge number

mjarun777 + 1 comment dr^1000000005 will take lot of time to complete how to avoid that

pasupuletiganes1 + 0 comments do fast exponentiation

yogesh_gawade010 + 0 comments (Nr * Dr -1 ) % P = ((Nr % P) * (Dr^-1 % P)) % P, is not correct equation. (Dr^(p-1))%p = 1(a^(p-1)-1 is divisible by p) ((Nr * Dr^-1 ) % P)*(Dr^(p-1))%p) = (Dr^(p-1))%p*1 (Dr^(p-1))%p = ((Nr * Dr^-1 ) % P)*(Dr^(p-1))%p)%p = (Nr*Dr^(-1)*Dr^(p-1))%p =(Nr*Dr*(p-2))%p

collin_jakubik + 0 comments [deleted]

bazuka_ + 3 comments finally solved after one month.

raj_yadav29oct + 3 comments Bro i am getting run time error on my c# code can you help me with that-

static void Main(string[] args) { int t =Convert.ToInt32(Console.ReadLine()); while(t>0) { string[] data =Console.ReadLine().Split(' '); ulong[] data1 = Array.ConvertAll(data, ulong.Parse); ulong N = data1[0]; ulong M = data1[1]; ulong newM = M - 1; ulong topfact = 1; ulong belowfact1 = 1; ulong belowfact2 = 1; ulong result = 0; for (ulong i=1;i<=(N+ newM);i++) { topfact = topfact * i; if(i<=N) { belowfact1 = (belowfact1 * i); } if (i <= newM) { belowfact2 = belowfact2 * i; } } result = (topfact / (belowfact1 * belowfact2))%1000000007; Console.WriteLine(result); t--; } Console.Read(); }

bazuka_ + 1 comment Actually the answer is

(m+n-1)C(n)=(m+n-1)!/ ((m-1)!)*n!)

and the forumula

Ncr=(n-1)c(r-1)+ (n-1)c(r)

now you can apply dp you may take help of this function as it is little bit tuff for me to understand c# that's why iam writing this function

`cpp

for (i = 0; i <= n; i++) { for (j = 0; j <= k; j++) {

`if (j == 0 || j == i)//as nc0=ncn=1; C[i][j] = 1; else C[i][j] = ((C[i-1][j-1])%mod +( C[i-1][j])%mod)%mod; } }`

`

now you can return the desired answer .

Now in your code this line

result = (topfact / (belowfact1 * belowfact2))%1000000007; will get run-time error or tle as your modulus approach formula is not correct as

(a * b) % mod = ((a % mod) * (b % mod)) % mod, (a / b ) % mod = ((a % mod) * (b^-1 % mod)) % mod,

and one more reason is that the

(topfact / (belowfact1*belowfact2))

will not work properly .

if problem persist then feel free to contact for further

clarification or you may take help of my c code

....

tamim447 + 0 comments k means m..?

vishu006 + 0 comments Hey take a look at this if it helps

from math import factorial n=int(raw_input()) for i in range(n): a,b=map(int,raw_input().split()) print (factorial(a+b-1)/(factorial(a)*factorial(b-1)))%1000000007

g_sosacuervo1 + 0 comments I believe if you try with N=1000 and M=1000, you will get the run time error. Basically, 1000!*999>ulong.MAX, in other words, it should give you kind of overflow.

Mohit_Yadav_389 + 0 comments Nice!

rejwancse10 + 1 comment will you please make me understand the logic of the problem?

codedeepesh + 0 comments logic is simple there are total m 1's and n 0's now you fix one 1 at starting of the string so you have m-1 1's now we have arrange them m+n-1!/(m-1!)(n!)

NiCkSs + 0 comments Compact Python 3 solution with built-in pow (performing modular exponentiation) and factorial.

import math q=int(input()) P=10**9+7 for _ in range(q): [n,m]=list(map(int,input().split())) m=m-1 num=math.factorial(n+m)%P den=math.factorial(n)*math.factorial(m) den=pow(den,P-2,P) print((num*den)%P)

LINKONRUHUL + 2 comments I think this code is better than the editorial code to understand! First, calculate all combinations from 1 to 2000 using this fromula

**(ncR=(n-1)c(R-1)+(n-1)cR)**.Then just find the appropriate result according to the problem satement!#include <bits/stdc++.h> #define ___ ios_base::sync_with_stdio(false);cin.tie(NULL); #define div 1000000007 using namespace std; int com[2017][2017]; int main() { int n,r,a,b,c; for(n=0; n<=2000; n++) { for(r=0; r<=n; r++) { if(r==0 || r==n) com[n][r]=1; else com[n][r]=(com[n-1][r-1]+com[n-1][r])%1000000007; } } cin>>c; while(c--) { cin>>a>>b; cout<<com[a+b-1][b-1]<<endl; } return 0; }

mjarun777 + 0 comments do u think its easy to find 4M values

rejwancse10 + 0 comments for(n=0; n<=2000; n++) { for(r=0; r<=n; r++) { if(r==0 || r==n) com[n][r]=1; else com[n][r]=(com[n-1][r-1]+com[n-1][r])%1000000007; } }

`i am not getting why this two loops are being used sir will you please make me understnad with example?`

aayush_break + 1 comment It took me a while to understand the logic , but there's a catch in the problem and it's not that hard to simplify it...

fo eg: string x=11100 for the string to start from 1, just fix the position of one of the ones(1s), hence you get

`(1) (1100)`

now we need to find possible combinations from those 4 string digits since we have already fixed the '1' hence,

`(4)c(noOfZeroes)= 4!/2!(4-2)!=6(ans)`

That's all, i did it in java so i used BigInteger for calc.

ebrucecfa + 0 comments Perfect example of why one should not commence coding too soon. I took my dog for a nice walk while thinking about this problem. This idea came too me pretty quickly.

- Read inputs.
- Grab getFactorial method that uses BigInteger.
- Write getCominations method.
- Write output for ea test case.

Below are some helpful Java methods

public static BigInteger getFactorial(int num) { BigInteger result = BigInteger.ONE; for (int i = 1; i <= num; i++) result = result.multiply(BigInteger.valueOf(i)); return result; } // getFactorial public static BigInteger getCombinations(int numTotal, int numZeros) { BigInteger result = BigInteger.ONE; BigInteger modulo = BigInteger.valueOf(1000000007); result = getFactorial(numTotal).divide((getFactorial(numZeros).multiply(getFactorial(numTotal-numZeros)))); return result.remainder(modulo); } // getCombinations

superadirockz + 3 comments Python

def solve(n, m): k=math.factorial(n+m-1) a=math.factorial(n)*math.factorial(m-1) k=k//a return (k%1000000007)

swtchaudhari490 + 0 comments Thank you so much!!

sravaniteja + 1 comment def fact(a): p=1 if(a==0): return p; else: while(a!=0): p = p*a a = a-1 return p t = int(input()) for i in range(t): m,n = map(int,input().strip().split()) print((int(fact(m+n-1)/(fact(m)*fact(n-1))))%(1000000007))

whats wrong in this code?

superadirockz + 1 comment use integer divison '//' in place of '/' in 'fact(m+n-1)/(fact(m)*fact(n-1))'

sravaniteja + 0 comments Thank you

nickbaxter883 + 0 comments Wow I simply assumed the numbers would get too large for that to work. Python is awesome! I know it automatically resizes ints to longs. I guess it does that for BigInts too. On harder challenges I'd be careful about timeout, but this looks like a much cleaner solution if the judge will run it. Much cleaner than the Python solution I posted!

1616410176_CS3C + 0 comments This is the easiest hard question i have ever solved ,just use factorials to solve the question

nickbaxter883 + 0 comments Cannot modulus at end of calculation or numbers will get too large obviously. But cant moduls from very beginning either while still needing to divide by a factorial. Start doing the modulus as soon as the factorial is completely divided out.

def choose(n, k): # = n*...*(n-k+1) / k! prod = 1 kVal = 2 for i in range(k): prod *= n-i if kVal <= k: while kVal <= k and prod%kVal == 0: prod //= kVal kVal += 1 else: prod %= 1000000007 return prod % 1000000007

angshuk_nag + 0 comments solved it but getting timeout error

angshuk_nag + 0 comments what does terminated due to timeout imply ? .. my code is running smoothly :(

Sort 77 Discussions, By:

Please Login in order to post a comment